Informal Public Consultation on the organisation of Primary Education in Tibshelf
Informal Public Consultation
Derbyshire County Council wishes to consult all interested parties on the
organisation of the schools in Tibshelf for the education of primary-aged
The former Tibshelf School site occupies an area of 58,839 square metres
in the centre of the village of Tibshelf. Tibshelf School moved to its new
location on the edge of the village in November 2013. At the time of
leaving, there were extensive school buildings on site, playing fields,
tennis courts, an all-weather pitch and a changing block. The all-weather
pitch and changing block had been funded with a partial grant from the
Football Foundation. All the sports facilities were replicated on the new
school site and are available for community use. Since the school’s
departure, the buildings (with the exception of the changing block) have
been demolished on safety grounds. The changing block and playing
fields have continued to be used by a local football club and the athletics
club. There is access across the site to the allotments.
In April/May 2016, there was a public consultation to consider the future
of primary education in Tibshelf and the disposal of surplus land on the
former Tibshelf School site. Derbyshire County Council’s Cabinet
considered the outcome of that consultation in July 2016 and the decision
was made to apply for permission to dispose of the surplus land. The
decision on the future of primary education in Tibshelf would be the
subject of further consultation. The Education and Skills Funding Agency
approved the disposal of surplus land in 2018 and therefore the Authority
is wishing to formulate its plans for the site.
Issues for Consultation
The availability of a site on the former Tibshelf School site creates an
opportunity to review the organisation of primary school provision in the
village. There is scope to effectively merge the two schools and create a
primary school. Primary schools are seen to have a number of advantages
over separate infant and junior schools, and in recent years, a number of
infant and junior schools have merged. The advantages are set out below:
• A primary school is able to organise and coordinate the teaching
across the primary years, and there is no need for a transition
between infant and junior schools; the transition from infant to junior
can be unsettling for some children and impact on educational
• The Infant and Junior schools in Tibshelf are not located on the
same sites and, as a consequence, parents may have children in
two schools at separate locations within the town, presenting travel
and time issues in getting children to school.
The ‘merger’ of the two schools could be achieved in one of two ways.
The first is for the two governing bodies to decide to form a ‘federation’.
Under a federation, the two schools can have a single governing body and
head teacher and effectively operate as a single school, although they
remain distinct in some respects such as separate Ofsted inspections,
budgets and admissions. The alternative would be for the Authority to
undertake a formal legal process to close the two existing schools and
open a new primary school. Under current legislation, the new primary
school can remain a maintained school under Derbyshire County Council.
In financial terms however it would operate with a single budget and this
may adversely affect the viability of the school. The federation option has
many of the benefits of a single school but can be put in place with less
Derbyshire County Council is proposing that the all-weather pitch and
changing block should remain and an area of 28,700 square metres be
retained to build a new school which would offer modern facilities and
enhance the quality of education.
The Junior School is on a very small site and there is no scope for
In order to access the former Tibshelf School site, since the last
consultation, it has become clear that the Infant & Nursery School would
at least have to be partially demolished to provide acceptable access for
any development and therefore if the decision is made to utilise the site
for a school, the new building would accommodate both the junior and
infant pupils regardless of the organisation of the school. The surplus land
including the site of the current Town End Junior School would then be
available for disposal.
The proposed project will be developed in more detail if this consultation
establishes support for the proposal. The cost of building a new school to
accommodate all of the primary-aged children in Tibshelf is estimated to
be in the region of £7m. The value of the land for disposal is estimated to
be around £2.35m. The balance of funding would be provided by
Derbyshire County Council from its Capital Programme. The details of the
project, including the access to the site, would be subject to further
consultation as part of the planning process.
1. Do you prefer the Junior and Infant Schools to remain on separate
2. Do you think Town End Junior School and Tibshelf Infant & Nursery
School should be co-located and operate as a federation?
3. Do you think the Junior and the Infant & Nursery School should
close and be re-established as a new primary school?
Cabinet will consider all views expressed during this consultation before
deciding on the future of primary education in Tibshelf. The consultation
will commence on Thursday 14 March 2019. If you require the
consultation document in any alternative format such as large print or
braille please contact Sue Pegg. If you would like to respond to this
consultation, please e-mail or write to Sue Pegg
(email@example.com) Development Section, Chatsworth Hall,
Chesterfield Road, Matlock. DE4 3FW by Friday 10 May 2019.